| ID |
Prio |
Originator |
Type |
Status |
Effort |
Date |
| 32 |
Admin update pages should be standardized for better alignment of data |
| |
2 |
Nithin |
Enhancement |
In Progress |
High |
06/01/2008 |
|
|
| 31 |
Differentiate malayalam and manglish lyrics |
| |
2 |
Devi Pillai |
Enhancement |
In Progress |
High |
07/24/2008 |
Comments: Technical Info: Tagging is required. We would also need a way to submit these two types without overwriting each other
Close the Details
|
| 30 |
Architects page pictures does not align with the names |
| |
1 |
Adarsh KR |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Low |
Aug 21,2008 |
Comments: Aligned the names and photos and provided a darker background for the architect section Technical Info: Better formatting is required
Close the Details
|
| 29 |
Find a way to remove spurious comments |
| |
1 |
Devi Pillai |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Medium |
Aug 10,2008 |
Comments: Will provide an option for removing this from the edit screen for Admins Technical Info: We can either not commit the comments real time or find a way to remove that
Close the Details
|
| 28 |
When songs are displayed and sorted sometimes songs from the same movie does not list next to each other |
| |
1 |
Rajagopal |
Bug |
Closed |
Low |
Feb 20,2008 |
|
|
| 27 |
Just wanted to know if you people happen to have a collection of the comedy songs released in Malayalam. I just wanted to have a collection of that you know. As it is the site doesn’t have a means of hunting down songs by such criteria. Please let me know if you have a list of comedy songs alone. |
| |
2 |
Vipin |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
Feb 11,2008 |
Comments: There is a behind the scenes effort happening to categorize songs by Genres in addition to several other efforts. This is undocumented still since not all songs have been tagged accordingly
Technical Info: http://malayalasangeetham.info/secure/MalayalaSangeetham/php/createSongIndex.php?txt=Comedy&stype=genre&txt2=&stype2=song_start&txt3=&stype3=song_start&txt4=&stype4=song_start&txt5=&stype5=song_start&submit=Find+Songs
Close the Details
|
| 26 |
I have noticed in a few places where the year is shown diffrently against songs in a same movie. Example Film : Ente Mohangal Poovaninju year shown 1981 and 1982. LIkeiwise there are few which please note !
Thanks for the wonderful site and greate effort! |
| |
1 |
Babu |
Bug |
Closed |
Low |
Feb 12,2008 |
Comments: 14 out of 3975 movies had this problem you reported ! All of these have been fixed. Let me know if you encounter this again. Technical Info: Ran syncUpYears.php
Close the Details
|
| 25 |
Under movie search, at present the search contains fields for Movie name, Year, Lyricist, Music Director and Director of movie. Can you provide another field for singer too?
Then it is easy to search for combinations. For instance, if i want to know about vayalar - devarajan - susheela songs, this search will help. |
| |
1 |
Ajay Nair |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
Jan 28,2008 |
Comments: Multi-level AND search has been implemented. Hope to implement OR soon ! Thanks for the request Technical Info:
Close the Details
|
| 24 |
Add actor and actress names to the movies for easier identification |
| |
2 |
Reshma Veettil |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
Jan 28,2008 |
|
|
| 23 |
When a movie has more than one lyricist and composer sometimes specific songs by those composer/lyricists may not be known yet. In that case we provide all the composer/lyricist name for each of the songs in the movie. On the flip side you might have a situation where a movie will have 2 songs by 1 composer and 2 others by another. In those cases, we need to put an asterisk of something to indicate that the movie has more than one composer/lyricist |
| |
1 |
Rajagopal |
Enhancement |
Open |
Medium |
Dec 3,2007 |
|
|
| 22 |
Hi Ajay,
One thing i noticed was that there is redundant code in the html which makes loading a big page take very long time.
eg: i seached for the letter "a" in movie names of songs and the resulting html was 24 MB in size :-D
Found that the code contains hyperlinks
this is rewritten for each line.
Instead of that you can put a reference to a javascript function, which does this forwarding to search. |
| |
2 |
Anoop |
Enhancement |
Closed |
High |
Dec 8,2007 |
Comments: This needs updating the current code. Technical Info: The probability of occurrence is very low. However this needs to be fixed
Close the Details
|
| 21 |
Can you also tell me if songs search results can be downloaded to xls format?
Or as a printable big list? (currently its 25 results per page) |
| |
0 |
Anoop |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Low |
Dec 8,2007 |
Comments: Undocumented options are published Technical Info: Instructions to do so is posted in the AboutUs.org link from the MSI page
Close the Details
|
| 20 |
Paginate dynamic song search pages |
| |
1 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Medium |
Nov 4,2007 |
Comments: For users who wants to download data, the static pages are more convenient Technical Info: Dynamic song search pages currently spit out thousands of results in some cases. This is highly inconvenient for most users
Close the Details
|
| 19 |
Enhance Static Pages |
| |
2 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Medium |
Oct 21,2007 |
Comments: This could be used for syndication purposes Technical Info: Static Pages can include comments from key contributors etc
Close the Details
|
| 18 |
Provide RSS feeds for MSI data |
| |
2 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Closed |
High |
Oct 20,2007 |
Comments: The challenge here is to figure out what should be included for subscription Technical Info: Implement XML files for simple syndication mechanisms
Close the Details
|
| 17 |
Move help to a wiki |
| |
2 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Closed |
High |
Oct 25.2007 |
Comments: Oct 25,2007
Preliminary move has been completed. More to follow Technical Info: Consider moving the help and descriptive texts from various parts of the site to somewhere similar to AboutUs.org
Close the Details
|
| 16 |
If you can list out the music directors, lyricists, singers through alphabetical order, that will be fantastic. Then search becomes much easier.
|
| |
1 |
Ajay Nair |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Medium |
Oct 29,2007 |
Comments: Technical Info: Static file creation utility to be updated to include this request
Close the Details
|
| 15 |
Add KPAC Drama Songs |
| |
2 |
Adarsh KR |
Enhancement |
Closed |
High |
Sep 29,2007 |
Comments: dear Ajayettan,
Do you have the details of Drama songs like Ponnarivaal, bali kudeerangale..etc
if we can provide that details in the near future, it will be nice ?!!
what do you think? will it be a difficult task for us? Technical Info: This is to be transcribed from the book on KPAC Songs (Which I have a copy of)
Oct 25,2007
First pass of this is completed, where the names of the plays and the songs in them are currently available from the homepage. We still need the year of origination and the singer names. So I'm keeping this item open
Close the Details
|
| 14 |
Generate logos for MSI branding |
| |
3 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Closed |
High |
Sep 21,2007 |
Comments: A more meaningful logo that brings together music, language, artists etc. need to be in place Technical Info: First version created and pages are updated
Close the Details
|
| 13 |
Tagging Unreleased and Dubbing movies more clearly |
| |
1 |
Shakeeb Vakkom |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Medium |
Sep 29,2007 |
Comments: Real database nu vendi ingane cheythaal nannaayirikkunnu
Release aaya chithrangalkku Year kodukkaam
Release aakattha chithrangalkku Year nte sthaanatth NR (not released) UR (un released) enno mark cheythaal ............
Mattonnu
State record l dubbing movies kaanaarilla
varshatthil 10 to 15 dubbing chithrangal varaarundu
Ithinaayi (D) enno matto mark cheythaal kollaamaayirunnu
Ithu verum abhipraayam maathramaanu. Technical Info:
Close the Details
|
| 12 |
Create user profiles |
| |
1 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Medium |
Sep 10,2007 |
Comments: Technical Info: Obtain information from active contributors and provide a link for easy access
Close the Details
|
| 11 |
Information and Trivia on key malayalam music personalities |
| |
1 |
Pattinte Paalazhi |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
Sep 3, 2007 |
Comments: I have a suggestion.
On the lines of what have been added on the awards front,can t we bolster the information content of the site - taking it to the next level,in a way.
Say,one could start off by providing categorised information on the personalities, featured on the gallery.For a singer it could be something like - first film,first song,first duet,year,movie, trivia etc.
There is an abundance of information - interesting, insightful, hitherto unkown at a broader level - floating in media,books, web etc.This would be an opportunity to collect them at one place as we come across them,verify the information we already know with others and eventually get at a source of reliable,validated info.
One could seek inputs from our members (have come across an amazing cross section of knowledgeable people here - Shakeeb,Suresh Warrier,the gentleman from Bahrain - can t place his name,and other esteemed contributors to this site..)
With time we could aim for a one stop shop for CONTENT relating to music at MSI.
My sense is,this will also promote a more vibrant participation and discussion from our members and would turn out to be an enriching experience for all of us creating the best info database in existence today.
Technical Info:
Close the Details
|
| 10 |
Explore the possibility of subdomains in MSI for musicial personalities |
| |
2 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Open |
Medium |
Sep 1,2007 |
Comments: Adarsh is already doing some pages like this. Would he be interested in bringing this under the MSI umbrella? Technical Info: How about raveendran.malayalasangeetham.info and similar pages to provide an in depth analysis of life and works musical greats
Close the Details
|
| 9 |
Find and add missing Tharangini Mappila Pattukal |
| |
1 |
PP Kabeer |
Enhancement |
Open |
Medium |
Sep 1, 2007 |
Comments: Please include muslim devotional songs & Mappilappattu albums also released by Tharangini Technical Info: Updated Sep 29, 2007
Shakeeb has been adding several of these albums. Will keep the item open for some more time
Close the Details
|
| 8 |
Provide a gateway / Portal for Malayalam music related books |
| |
1 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
Aug 10,2007 |
Comments: Several of us have books that talk about various musical trivia and such. Provide a database of that for easier reference
A reference section has been added, but this contains only about 30+ books. Will keep this item open until we have a better handle on the item Technical Info:
Close the Details
|
| 7 |
Use of Wiki and structured data |
| |
2 |
Raycas |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
June 20,2007 |
Comments: - Ability to add comments:
We could really integrate popular standard wikis or bulletin boards right along with a song to capture details that could make the whole thing more easy to use. Specific ideas on how to do that are quite welcome.
- Data redundancy in movie names....:
Yes. This is indeed true; primarily because of 2 reasons (1) I'm not a database designer :) (2) More importantly, the data evolved in this database over time and my preference was more data to move it closer to our goal of being a "comprehensive database" over efficiency whenever I had to do a trade-off. This led to a situation where the movie database and the songs database were separately built and hooked up using some scripts. I'm in complete agreement that the time has come for us to remove the redundancies and the make the databases work as it should. I don't expect this to be too difficult
- Selectable values for the fields such as Singer/Musician ....:
The reason for not implementing this for the Songs (Though we still have that feature for Movies Search) is because we have 1749 unique singers,350+ musicians and about similar number for lyricists. Typically it is not considered to be very convenient to load up drop-down menus with this much data. Some browsers break with simple html implementation and efficiency will be compromised if we dynamically load up the page (server side scripts like php) from the database every time one loads it.
I have kept the "Movies" and "Songs" implementation different primarily to spur the thought of usability among users and find out if they have a preference for one over the other. An efficient implementation these days could be using "AJAX word completion" (http://ajax.asp.net/ajaxtoolkit/AutoComplete/AutoComplete.aspx) type features that would provide a more context sensitive searches. Unfortunately that particular technology is beyond my capabilities and we need some tech-savvy folks to be involved in this to make that kind of a change. If I don't get any help in that area, the soonest I will get to it will be Spring of 2008. If we can find someone who has time and essential skills to do this, that would be the most ideal situation.
Sometime in the near future, I will post my Todo List here so that any of you who are interested can recommend your priorities. I will bump up the priority of removing data redundancies to make user visible issues such as different spellings for movies in Movie DB and Songs DB go away
Technical Info: Well, even if it doesn't make that impression, MSI is actually meant
as a collaborative site. means, if you don't find an information there
which should be there, then you can submit it on your own. just above
the song listing there is a link saying "Click here to submit a
missing song".
i think this collaborative feature could be something to enhance
further, like a wiki. would be nice if people could submit things more
conveniently.
by the way, one thing i noticed: it seems the data that is visible in
the songs view like especially movie name, isn't the same as the one
visible in the movie view. seems there is some kind of redundancy in
the data. like for example it is "Kalippattam" in the movie view, but
in songs view for one of the songs (Mozhiyazhakum) its "Kalippaattam",
with double "a".
aren't the songs and the movies linked at a conceptual level? i mean
if you click on the + in one line, then isn't it possible to take
along the attribute "movie" to the next page (song view) and place it
under "Movie"?
or is it because of the submit song feature that both of these things
(movie and song, but also composer, lyricist etc.) are uncoupled? like
is it the mistake of the person who submitted it?
wouldn't it be possible to offer the existing music directors,
lyricists etc. names when submitting something instead of letting the
people write it on their own? with a drop down box? then you could get
rid of these mistakes i think. but somehow it sounds too simple that i
think you have good reasons why you didn't implement it like that. :)
Close the Details
|
| 6 |
Portal entries looks inconsistent |
| |
1 |
Pattinte Paalazhi |
Bug |
Closed |
Medium |
Jun 14,2007 |
Comments: I'll take a look at this as soon as possible and fix them.
My guess is that the last round of cleanup of spurious entries in the database didn't necessarily get reflected on the portal pages (since these are static pages created to make it more conducive for search engines). A couple of notes though: "Vani Jaya" is a different singer than Vani Jairam. 13 AD is a band that played for the movie Daivathinte Vikruthikal. Rest all looks to be errors that I need to fix
PP, All the identified infractions have been rectified. "Nayidin" apparently is how that singer prefers to be idenified, "Rehna" is AR Rahman's sister, who now has a consistent spelling in MSI.
I'm continuing to look as time permits; when you come across more, don't hesitate to forward them. Technical Info:
A glance through the Portal section for solo singers throws up some
strange names and duplicate entries.This scetion needs a sanity
check.
I am sure one can attempt to rectify this quickly as this would
involve minimum surfing throught the database,if one does it from
the portal.
Some such entries :
- There are multiple versions of the same name ( KJ Yesudas,KS
chithra,Vidyasagar..)Yesudas appears in various shades all over..
- Splelling mistakes (Sathessh babu,Vani Jaya)
- Strange names (M,13 AD,duet,chorus..)
Request you to take a look,please.
Hi ASM,
Thanks for your quick response;and the 6 long hours of boy
scouting :-)
Its all fine now (there s just one, one and only yesudas there now)
barring a few odd cases,one came across.
-----
Some duplicate entries :
Kanjangad Ramachandran - Kanjangadu Ramachandran
Meboob /Mehboob
P Leelam Santha P Nair ( this can t appear in a list of solos,right)
Madhuri, P Madhuri
Periyanayaki, PA Periyanayaki
Rahana / Rahna (are they different)
Santhosh Kesav / Santhosh Keshav / Santosh Keshav
Salma George / Selma George
Seerkazhi /Sheerkazhi Govindarajan
SP Balasubramaniyam /manium
V Dakshinamooorthy/V Dakshinamoorthy
Chorus,Instrumental
Nayidin - One couldn t understand this.
Close the Details
|
| 5 |
Provide Recording company information |
| |
3 |
Paayal |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
Aug 1,2007 |
Comments: First of all let me congratulate you for your efforts for creating such a vast database of Malyalam movies. My name is Paayal & I just want to request you to also add the name of the Music Publishing Company of available movies. We should not forget their contribution.
You can ask the data from the various music companies who publish the cds & cassettes.
More info from Paayal on Aug 8:
I know some Music company names which can provide you the details required for your database.
The List is as follow :-
Gramophone companies pvt. ltd
Satyam Audios
Ranjini
Tharangini
Audiotrack Music Company
Geetham
These are the few music companies which I know. I can help You in getting some data from Saregama (Gramophone) but the process will take time.
With warm & musical regards,
Paayal
Technical Info:
Excellent idea. We will be more than happy to add those names. If you know of some specific music companies who are active now, that will be a great start
Close the Details
|
| 4 |
Integrate Google Analytics |
| |
2 |
Ajay |
Enhancement |
Closed |
Low |
July 2007 |
Comments: Register at the Google site and get the analytics ID Technical Info:
Close the Details
|
| 3 |
Better Handle the spaces between the song names |
| |
1 |
Harry S Anchan |
Bug |
Open |
Medium |
June 27,2007 |
|
|
| 2 |
Provide better inputs to the search engine crawls |
| |
1 |
Vikas |
Enhancement |
Open |
Medium |
June 22,2007 |
Comments: 1) I believe you're using some database to store these details. Not sure
why you have to add to/create your own dictionary when some databases
like Oracle provide functions like "soundex('string' )" which will take
care of small spelling mistakes ('th' vs 't', 'a' vs 'aa' etc.).
2) Again, due to perhaps data being in a database, I feel you're missing a lot
of search hits. I just did a following search in google.
site:www.malayalasa ngeetham. info "oru vattam"
It returned no hits whereas it was very well there in the system. I don't
think any search engine "crawls" databases. One suggestion to get more
hits would be to create pages, perhaps in a batch mode, which will list
all, or atleast most searched, details. For a person who knows this site
it's not a problem. But for someone who doesn't, he's missing a lot. Could
you please think over this.
Technical Info: First off, I have considered using Soundex function (..and we used to have it in the first version in 2003) but this doesn't make a lot of sense in several cases due to the fact that the words are transliterated from malayalam. I will try to put these back and use in conjunction with the built-in dictionary and see if that helps further. Stay tuned
Updates: Aug 2007
Significant strides have been taken here. Typical monthly usage of the site has shot up from around 50,000 hits to 5 times that amount. However there are still some unresolved issues. I am going to leave this open for now. Close the Details
|
| 1 |
Use Unicode for better language search |
| |
2 |
Ashwin Sudhir |
Enhancement |
Open |
High |
April 2007 |
Comments: I don't know the technical feasibility, but it'd be best to convert
everything to unicode so that "Sounds Like" won't be needed at all.
The Unicode Consortium hasn't finalized the encoding for malayalam yet
, I think, but that'd be the general direction to move. My suggestion
would be to use a standard transliteration scheme like 'Mozhi' for the
time-being and when Malayalam encoding has been standardized, convert
everything to unicode with existing apps like varamozhi or hack up
something for our purpose. Admittedly it'll take a lot of work, but if
there're enough volunteers, I guess this can be done, albeit
gradually. Please everyone voice your views on this. Technical Info:
Close the Details
|